Law-Psychology Research in the U.S

Guest Lecture

Emma Marshall, JD, MA

Plan for today

Previous Research Reviews

Selective reviews with narrow focus

Scientific Review Papers

Approved by AP-LS committee

  • Eyewitness Identification Procedures: Recommendations for lineups and Photospreads Wells et al (1998)

  • Police-induced Confessions: Risk Factors and Recommendations Kassin et al (2010)

  • Policy and Procedure Recommendations for the Collection and Preservation of Eyewitness Identification Evidence Constanzo & Levett (2020)

Sources of Law in the U.S.

Civil Law

Criminal Law

Law in the U.S.

State vs Federal Law

State vs Federal Law

40 Years of Law & Human Behavior

  • Official journal of APLS
    • Peer reviewed
    • Multidisciplinary forum
    • Range of articles:
      • original research
      • reviews
      • theory papers

Journal Impact

Journal 2017 2022 Comparison
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 23.55 21.36
Psychological Bulletin 14.46 23.03
American Psychologist 9.73 16.36
Harvard Law Review 3.94 6.03
Law and Human Behavior 2.16 3.87
Psych, Public Policy & Law 1.93 3.32
Applied Cognitive Psychology 1.67 2.36
Behavioral Sciences & the Law 0.96 2.57
Law and Society Review 1.73 2.59
Legal & Criminological Psych 1.65 1.76
Psychology, Crime and Law 0.69 1.75
Law and Social Inquiry 1.14 1.40

Method

  • Comprehensive review

  • Four research assistants

    • Overlapped on n = 25%
      • On average, each coded 450 articles (range: 447-455)
      • N = 1320 articles from 1977-2014 (vol. 38, issue 3)
  • Removed non-research items

Coded Variables

  • General Information
    • Research topic(s)
    • Citations (#)
  • Research Method
    • Sample
    • Specific research method
  • Connection to Psychology
    • Area of psychology
    • Application of theory
  • Connection to Law
    • Area of Law
    • References to case law
    • References to statute(s)
    • References to state or fed constitutions
    • References to policy

Primary Research Areas

“all other” research areas

Types of “Witnesses”

Types of “Witnesses”

Child Witnesses ~4%

Eyewitness Memory ~ 12%

Expert Witnesses ~4%

Research Areas Over Time

  • Child Witnesses

  • Expert Witnesses

  • Eyewitness Memory

  • Jury Decision Making

  • Juvenile Law

  • Mental Health

  • Public Policy

  • Risk Assessment

Witnesses

Risk Assessment

Mental health

Public Policy

Juvenile Law

Jury decision-making

Eyewitness 📈 > Juries 📉

Citations Over Time

Most Cited Articles

Risk Assessment

Hanson & Thornton (2000)

Eyewitness memory

Wells et al (1998)

Most Cited (Top 20) Articles

Author (Year) Research Area 2017 2022
Hanson and Thornton (2000)
Improving risk assessments for sex offenders: a comparison of three actuarial scales
Risk assessment; sex offenders
994
1578
Wells et al. (1998)
Eyewitness identification procedures: Recommendations for lineups and photospreads
Eyewitnesses and memory
883
1346
Bornstein (1999)
The ecological validity of jury simulations: Is the jury still out?
Jury or judicial decision making
694
1059
Rice et al. (1992)
An evaluation of a maximum security therapeutic community for psychopaths and other mentally disordered offenders
Psychopathy; mentally ill offenders and psych. Patients
627
951
Steinberg and Cauffman (1996)
Maturity of judgment in adolescence: Psychosocial factors in adolescent decision making
Competency and criminal responsibility; juvenile justice
570
1010
Harris et al. (1991)
Psychopathy and violent recidivism
Psychopathy; criminal offending/recidivism
547
850
Loftus et al. (1987)
Some facts about 'weapon focus'
Eyewitnesses and memory
518
885
Grisso and Appelbaum (1995)
The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. III---Abilities of Patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments
Competency and criminal responsibility
493
643
Rice and Harris (1997)
Cross-validation and extension of the Violence Risk Appraisal Guide for child molesters and rapists
Risk assessment; sex offenders
463
662
Rice and Harris (2005)
Comparing effect sizes in follow-up studies: ROC area, Cohen's d, and r
General psych and law
458
1672
Grisso et al. (2003)
Juveniles' competence to stand trial: A comparison of adolescents' and adults' capacities as trial defendants
Juvenile justice; competency and criminal responsibility
443
810
Goodman and Reed (1986)
Age differences in eyewitness testimony
Eyewitnesses and memory
437
635
Slovic et al. (2000)
Violence risk assessment and risk communication: The effects of using actual cases, providing instruction, and employing probability versus frequency formats
Risk assessment
435
702
Kassin et al. (2010)
Police-induced confessions: Risk factors and recommendations
Confessions and interrogations
425
1017
Appelbaum and Grisso (1995)
The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. I---Mental Illness and competence to consent to treatment
Competency and criminal responsibility
424
618
Leistico et al. (2008)
A large-scale meta-analysis relating the hare measures of psychopathy to antisocial conduct
Risk assessment; psychopathy
424
930
Seagrave and Grisso (2002)
Adolescent development and the measurement of juvenile psychopathy
Psychopathy; juvenile justice
419
676
Steblay (1992)
A meta-analytic review of the weapon focus effect
Eyewitnesses and memory
406
656
Deffenbacher et al. (2004)
A meta-analytic review of the effects of high stress on eyewitness memory
Eyewitnesses and memory
402
749
Baker and Emery (1993)
When every relationship is above average--- Perceptions and expectations of divorce at the time of marriage
Family issues
390
552

Sample Used

Study Methodology

Area of Law

Area of Psychology

78% applied psychological theory

thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold thumbs-up-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold x-bold
thumbs-up-bold Yes x-bold No

Application of Psychological Theory

Summary

  • Most articles focused on similar topics
    • Few professional samples
    • Mostly criminal law
    • Limited to social or cognitive psychology
  • Room for growth!

Questions?